To make clinical trials equitable, cancer groups evaluate restrictive eligibility criteria

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on print

Emergent public-private partnerships (PPPs) have risen to the occasion to streamline and coordinate severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) vaccines. With these monumental efforts have come important public discussions about equitable access and representation in clinical trials (CTs).  

Equitable access to CTs—that is, the opportunity for all patients to access CTs that may offer improved outcomes and the evidence-based standard of care treatment that CTs offer—must be a priority.Improved access in CTs will benefit individual patients, and improving inclusiveness of trial populations will benefit all patients with a given disease. Clinicians will also have greater confidence in the generalizability of CT data to make informed treatment decisions. 

Eligibility criteria (EC), the inclusion and exclusion criteria written into trial protocols by the study sponsor, are intended to ensure patient safety. Overly restrictive EC, however, are a significant impediment to enrollment and equity, because they consistently exclude certain groups, particularly older adults, racial/ethnic minorities, and patients with previous/ongoing chronic medical conditions. 

While narrow EC are not intended to discriminate against any individual or group, that is the effect, and it is unacceptable. 

To access this subscriber-only content please log in or subscribe.

If your institution has a site license, log in with IP-login or register for a sponsored account.*
*Not all site licenses are enrolled in sponsored accounts.

Login Subscribe
Julia Beaver, MD
Chief of medical oncology, Oncology Center of Excellence, Deputy director (acting), Office of Oncologic Diseases, FDA Center for Drug Evaluation and Research
Thomas S. Uldrick, MD
Affiliate Professor, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center
Gwynn Ison, MD
Medical officer/ clinical reviewer,
FDA Office of Oncologic Diseases
Suanna S. Bruinooge, MPH
Director, Research Strategy & Operations Div., Center for Research and Analytics, American Society of Clinical Oncology
Caroline Schenkel, MSc
Manager, Research Analysis and Publications, American Society of Clinical Oncology
Edward S. Kim, MD, MBA, FACP, FASCO
Physician-in-Chief, Orange County; Vice Physician-in-Chief, City of Hope National Medical Center
Table of Contents

YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

Recently, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. posted a video montage featuring himself shirtless in jeans, working out with Kid Rock. The duo is in a blue-lit grotto with a cold plunge and sauna. Set to Kid Rock’s “Bawitdaba” and intercut with a selection of patriotic imagery, the video ends with the two men in a hot tub, chugging what appears to be milk.
In January, FDA released a draft guidance entitled “Minimal Residual Disease and Complete Response in Multiple Myeloma: Use as Endpoints to Support Accelerated Approval.” This release came roughly 20 months after the Oncologic Drugs Advisory Committee (ODAC) voted unanimously that minimal residual disease (MRD) negativity, in combination with complete response (CR), is an acceptable primary endpoint to support accelerated approval for multiple myeloma (MM) therapies. 
A three-year grant from Lilly to Roswell Park Comprehensive Cancer Center is bringing rich lung health resources to Indigenous workplaces located across North America. Collaborating with human resources specialists with Tribal Nations and communities covering many regions of the U.S. and Canada, Roswell Park’s Department of Indigenous Cancer Health team will provide lung cancer screening workflow resources, lung wellness education, and patient navigation services for thousands of eligible individuals.
Julia Beaver, MD
Chief of medical oncology, Oncology Center of Excellence, Deputy director (acting), Office of Oncologic Diseases, FDA Center for Drug Evaluation and Research
Thomas S. Uldrick, MD
Affiliate Professor, Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center
Gwynn Ison, MD
Medical officer/ clinical reviewer,
FDA Office of Oncologic Diseases
Suanna S. Bruinooge, MPH
Director, Research Strategy & Operations Div., Center for Research and Analytics, American Society of Clinical Oncology
Caroline Schenkel, MSc
Manager, Research Analysis and Publications, American Society of Clinical Oncology
Edward S. Kim, MD, MBA, FACP, FASCO
Physician-in-Chief, Orange County; Vice Physician-in-Chief, City of Hope National Medical Center

Never miss an issue!

Get alerts for our award-winning coverage in your inbox.

Login