Senate passes a “right to try” bill; Harm to patients comes next

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on email
Share on print

Patients for whom there are no existing treatments watch with desperation as a potentially helpful new drug spends years working its way from a lab bench, through clinical trials, and finally to the FDA, where reviewers consider it for approval.

To access this subscriber-only content please log in or subscribe.

If your institution has a site license, log in with IP-login or register for a sponsored account.*
*Not all site licenses are enrolled in sponsored accounts.

Login Subscribe
Kelly McBride Folkers
Research associate, Division of Medical Ethics, NYU School of Medicine
Lisa Kearns
Senior research associate, Division of Medical Ethics, NYU School of Medicine
Alison Bateman-House
Assistant professor in the Division, co-chair of NYU's Working Group on Compassionate Use and Pre-Approval Access.
Table of Contents

YOU MAY BE INTERESTED IN

For nearly 25 years, business executive Lou Weisbach and urologist Richard J. Boxer have argued that finding the money to finance the cures for devastating diseases is not as difficult as it appears. To start finding the cures, the U.S. Department of the Treasury needs to issue some bonds—$750 billion worth. Next, you hire CEOs—one...

There is general agreement that the United States spends too much on health care, especially on pharmaceuticals.  But what we spend on drugs is not simply a function of price. If eggs double in price, people can simply cut the number of eggs they eat in half.  Simply stated, cost is the product of (price per unit times the number of units purchased). 
What did President Richard M. Nixon and Senator Edward M. Kennedy have in common? They each played a pivotal role in the passage of the National Cancer Act signed by Nixon on Dec. 23, 1971. The NCA established the National Cancer Program authorizing the initial investment in the NCI-designated Cancer Centers Program. 
When I first proposed targeting PCNA (proliferating cell nuclear antigen) as a therapeutic approach, the response I got was: “No one will ever make a drug against PCNA. It’s undruggable.” The protein lacks enzymatic activity, has a disordered region, and binds to over 200 other proteins within the cell. From a traditional drug development perspective, these characteristics made PCNA an impossible target.
Kelly McBride Folkers
Research associate, Division of Medical Ethics, NYU School of Medicine
Lisa Kearns
Senior research associate, Division of Medical Ethics, NYU School of Medicine
Alison Bateman-House
Assistant professor in the Division, co-chair of NYU's Working Group on Compassionate Use and Pre-Approval Access.

Never miss an issue!

Get alerts for our award-winning coverage in your inbox.

Login